Why Do Two Retirement Projections Disagree on How Long Your Money Will Last?

Ross Marino |

Two retirement projections can disagree because they assume different withdrawals, model investment returns differently, or use different definitions of running out. If the earlier result makes you wonder whether you should spend less, start by comparing what your portfolio has to pay for in one full year. The reports may use the same spending number and still assume different withdrawals. Finding that difference gives you a better basis for deciding what you can afford to keep doing. [1]

Do both forecasts count the same expenses and income?

Start with the bills and purchases you expect to pay, including costs that arrive once or twice a year. Then look at the income expected to cover them. If a pension starts partway through the year, the portfolio may have to cover more in the months before it begins. The same annual spending can create a different withdrawal need if one forecast starts a benefit sooner or leaves a source of income out. [1]

Next find the tax line. A report can show household spending before income taxes and account for estimated taxes elsewhere in the forecast. Ask whether each report shows the amount leaving the investment account or the amount available after taxes. If money is withheld from a distribution, the deposit will be smaller than the withdrawal. Withholding is a payment toward the tax bill, and the eventual bill can differ. [2]

Suppose both reports use $36,000 and assume $4,000 for taxes paid from the portfolio in the same year. Other income is already accounted for. The meaning of the $36,000 determines what is left for spending.

When both forecasts say $36,000

$36,000 available to spend

$36,000 for spending plus $4,000 for taxes

$40,000 leaves the portfolio

$36,000 withdrawn in total

$36,000 withdrawn, including $4,000 to pay taxes

$32,000 available to spend

Illustration only. Both forecasts assume the same tax amount and other income.

What does each report mean by running out?

Ask the advisor to point to the first line that signals a problem. One report might identify the year the investment balance reaches zero. [3] Another might identify the first year a planned expense is only partially funded, or report how often spending is fully funded through a specified age across many simulated markets. The date, the balance and the share of simulated outcomes answer different questions. Check which accounts the result includes and how far each forecast runs. [4]

Then ask how each report treats returns. A steady-return illustration applies a set rate, while a simulation can test different paths, including declines early in retirement. Even if the average return looks similar, losses near the start can leave less invested to recover while you keep taking withdrawals. Compare the treatment of inflation and investment costs as well. If one report quotes a return before fees and the other uses a return after fees, the rates aren’t directly comparable. [3][4][5]

What should you ask to see side by side?

Bring both reports to an advisor and ask for a comparison that uses the same starting point. Use balances from the same date and include the same accounts. Line up the income start dates, the expenses you want to fund, and the estimated taxes. Ask the advisor to show how much would come out of your portfolio and how much you’d have left to spend after taxes in an early full year. Then agree on a common outcome to compare, such as whether spending is fully funded through the same age under the conditions tested. If the reports can’t show the same outcome, ask the advisor to run both sets of assumptions in one model. [6]

If the results still differ, ask to change one important assumption at a time. For example, ask the advisor to keep the budget fixed and show what changes if weaker returns arrive early. Then ask them to keep the return assumptions fixed while testing a spending change you would actually consider. That can help you see whether the disagreement points to a tradeoff you need to make or simply reflects different ways of calculating the forecast. [4][6]

Dovetail Principle: The Numbers Should Clarify the Decision, Not Promise the Future

Ask yourself what you would do differently if the earlier shortfall occurred. You may be comfortable making a future adjustment to optional spending. You may want more protection for housing, healthcare, or other costs you would find hard to cut. Seeing which assumption puts those choices under pressure makes the comparison useful today.

Which spending choice still feels workable?

Once you can explain the difference, return to the choice that made you look at the dates in the first place. If both forecasts support the spending you value under the same reasonable assumptions, you may be able to keep spending as planned and revisit that choice as conditions change. If the result hinges on a cost or income source you’re unsure about, decide what you could adjust and when you would revisit it. The date matters because of the decisions it brings into view for you now.

To see which assumptions are worth testing once the forecasts use the same starting facts, read Which Assumptions Matter Most in a Retirement Projection?.

About the author

Ross Marino, CFP®, CeFT®, is the Founder & CEO of Dovetail Financial and creator of Human-First Financial Guidance®. He helps people nearing or living in retirement connect their lives and wealth so that financial decisions become clearer, more personal, and easier to navigate.

Search another retirement question

Describe the question or enter a few topic words. You do not need to know the exact article title.

 

Notes

  1. Taking the Mystery Out of Retirement Planning, U.S. Department of Labor.
  2. Tax Withholding and Estimated Tax, Internal Revenue Service, Publication 505.
  3. Retirement Calculator, Financial Industry Regulatory Authority.
  4. Modeling the Impact of Inflation on Retirement Savings Portfolios, Society of Actuaries Research Institute.
  5. Measuring Sequence Returns Risk, Andrew Clare and coauthors, Risks.
  6. Interpreting the Practice Standard for Analyzing the Client’s Current Course of Action, CFP Board.

Disclosure

This content is provided by Dovetail Financial Group LLC (“Dovetail Financial”) for informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended as, and should not be construed as, individualized investment, tax, legal, or accounting advice; a recommendation to buy or sell any security; or a recommendation to adopt any investment strategy. Because each person’s situation is unique, readers should consult their own financial, tax, and legal professionals before taking action based on this content. Information contained herein is believed to be reliable, but its accuracy or completeness is not guaranteed. Any opinions expressed are current as of the date of publication and are subject to change without notice. All investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Asset allocation and diversification do not guarantee profits or protect against losses in declining markets. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results. Dovetail Financial Group LLC is a registered investment adviser. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Additional information about Dovetail Financial Group LLC, including Form ADV Part 2A and Form CRS, is available at adviserinfo.sec.gov. © 2026 Dovetail Financial Group LLC. All rights reserved.